.png&type=webp)
Football All-Americans
| Kodak Coaches First Team | ||
| Barry Bourassa | RB | 1991 |
| Dwayne Sabb | LB | 1991 |
| John Driscoll | OT | 1987 |
| Paul Dufault | C | 1985 |
| Dave Morton | OT | 1984 |
| Bill Burnham | RB | 1977 |
| Grady Vigneau | OT | 1977 |
| Bill Burnham | RB | 1976 |
| Kevin Martell | C | 1975 |
| Al Witteman | DT | 1968 |
| Ed Douglas | G | 1950 |
| American Football Coaches Association | ||
| Dylan Laube | AP | 2023 |
| Max Brosmer | QB | 2023 |
| Dylan Laube | AP | 2022 (2nd) |
| Casey DeAndrade | CB | 2016 |
| RJ Harris | WR | 2014 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2012 |
| Dino Vasso | DB | 2010 |
| Scott Sicko | TE | 2009 |
| Ricky Santos | QB | 2007 |
| David Ball | WR | 2006 |
| David Ball | WR | 2005 |
| Stephan Lewis | RB | 2002 |
| Jerry Azumah | TB | 1998 |
| Jerry Azumah | TB | 1997 |
| Mike Foley | DL | 1994 |
| Associated Press First Team | ||
| Josiah Silver | DE | 2024 |
| Dylan Laube | AP | 2022-23 |
| Mike Coccia | C | 2014 |
| RJ Harris | WR | 2014 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2012 |
| Scott Sicko | TE | 2008 |
| Ricky Santos | QB | 2007 |
| David Ball | WR | 2006 |
| David Ball | WR | 2005 |
| Jonathan Williams | TE | 2005 |
| Jerry Azumah | TB | 1998 |
| Walter Jones | OL | 1998 |
| Walter Camp First Team | ||
| Josiah SIlver | DE | 2024 |
| Dylan Laube | KR | 2022 |
| Neil O'Connor | WR | 2017 |
| Mike Coccia | C | 2014 |
| RJ Harris | WR | 2014 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2012 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2011 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2010 |
| Scott Sicko | TE | 2008 |
| Ricky Santos | QB | 2007 |
| David Ball | WR | 2006 |
| Ricky Santos | QB | 2006 |
| David Ball | WR | 2005 |
| Ricky Santos | QB | 2005 |
| Jonathan Williams | TE | 2005 |
| David Ball | WR | 2004 |
| Jerry Azumah | RB | 1998 |
| Barry Bourassa | RB | 1991 |
| HERO Sports | ||
|---|---|---|
| Dylan Laube | AP | 2022 |
| Stats Perform | ||
|---|---|---|
| Dylan Laube | AP | 2023 (1st) |
| Max Brosmer | QB | 2023 (1st) |
| Dylan Laube | AP | 2022 (1st) |
| Josiah Silver | DE | 2022 (3rd), 2024 (1st) |
| The Sports Network/Stats | ||
| Neil O'Connor | WR | 2017 (2nd) |
| Mike Coccia | C | 2014 (3rd) |
| RJ Harris | WR | 2014 (1st) |
| Harold Spears | TE | 2014 (2nd) |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2012 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2011 |
| College Sporting News | ||
| RJ Harris | WR | 2014 |
| Harold Spears | TE | 2014 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2012 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2010 |
| Brian McNally | DE | 2010 |
| College Sports Journal | ||
| Jared Smith | DT | 2012 |
| Phil Steele's First Team | ||
| Josiah Silver | DE | 2024 |
| Dylan Laube | AP | 2023 |
| Dylan Laube | AP | 2022 |
| Neil O'Connor | WR | 2017 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2011 |
| College Sports Madness | ||
| Neil O'Connor | WR | 2017 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2011 |
| Beyond Sports Network | ||
| Mike Coccia | C | 2014 (3rd) |
| Casey DeAndrade | CB | 2014 (3rd) |
| RJ Harris | WR | 2014 (1st) |
| Harold Spears | TE | 2014 (1st) |