.png&type=webp)
All-Conference First Team
| Player | Position | Year(s) |
| Geoff Aleva | DT | 1990,1991 |
| Jeff Allen | QB | 1976, 1977 |
| Alton Amidon | T | 1956 |
| Warren Armes | LB | 1994 |
| Paul Ashnault | G | 1953, 1954 |
| Jerry Azumah | TB | 1996, 1997, 1998 |
| David Ball | WR | 2004, 2005, 2006 |
| Jason Ball | C | 2001 |
| Brett Bashaw | LB | 2000 |
| Brett Bernier | DE | 1971 |
| Ed Booker | LB | 1972 |
| Paul Boulay | DT | 1986,1987 |
| Barry Bourassa | RB | 1990, 1991 |
| Mike Boyle | WR | 2008 |
| Norman Breault | WR | 1970 |
| Max Brosmer | QB | 2023 |
| Jim Bumpus | OG | 1985 |
| Bill Burnham | RB | 1975, 1976, 1977 |
| John Burnham | T | 1957 |
| Romande Carter | LB | 1996 |
| Tony Ciccone | OG | 1985 |
| Mike Coccia | OL | 2014 |
| Jim Concannon | DB | 1993, 1994 |
| Nick Couturier | OC | 2007 |
| Edward Cramer | G | 1961 |
| Matt Crispino | DL | 1998 |
| Paul D'Allesandro | G | 1961 |
| Casey DeAndrade | CB, PR | 2014, 2015, 2016 |
| Kevin Decker | QB | 2011 |
| Bill Dedrick | DE | 1977 |
| Richard Dewing | RB | 1952 |
| Steve Doig | LB | 1981 |
| Greg Donahue | LB | 1979 |
| Ed Douglas | G | 1951 |
| Pat Downey | C | 1997 |
| Dan Drewniak | C | 1969 |
| John Driscoll | OT | 1987 |
| Paul Dufault | C | 1985 |
| Dick Duffy | DB | 1977 |
| Earl Eddy | T | 1951 |
| Phil Estey | RB | 1966, 1967 |
| Mark Etro | S | 1975, 1977 |
| Richard Eustis | E | 1960 |
| Matt Evans | LB | 2011, 2012 |
| Eric Facey | PK | 1985 |
| John Flanagan | OG | 1984 |
| Joe Fleming | DL | 1994 |
| Mike Foley | DL | 1994, 1995 |
| Norm Ford | RB | 1988 |
| Terrance Fox | WR | 2010 |
| Francis Frasier | E | 1959 |
| David Gamble | WR | 1993 |
| Andre Garron | RB | 1983, 1984, 1985 |
| Arnold Garron | DB | 1982, 1983 |
| Dave Giguere | OG | 1973 |
| Alan Girroir | T | 1954 |
| Mike Gooden | S | 1982 |
| Dwayne Gordon | LB | 1992 |
| Paul Gorham | TE | 1982 |
| Basil Gregorios | G | 1956 |
| Charles Grzbielski | E | 1962 |
| R.J Harris | WR | 2012, 2013, 2014 |
| Stan Harrison | DB | 1986 |
| Jeff Hayes | OL | 1999 |
| Neal Herrick | E | 1952 |
| Edwin Holm | G | 1959 |
| Bob Hopkins | QB | 1971 |
| Bruce Huther | LB | 1985 |
| Ilia Jarostchuk | LB | 1984, 1985, 1986 |
| Ryan Jones | DB | 1989 |
| Walter Jones | OL | 1998 |
| Ken Kaplan | OT | 1980, 1982 |
| Rich Langlois | LB | 1973 |
| Mike Lanza | DT | 1974 |
| Dylan Laube | PR RB, PR, AP |
2022 2023 |
| Keith LeVan | WR | 2007 |
| Greg Lewis | DB | 1992 |
| Stephan Lewis | RB | 2002 |
| Paul Lindquist | T | 1960 |
| Marshall Litchfield | E | 1954 |
| Dave Loehle | WR | 1978, 1979 |
| Ray Lyons | DL | 1995 |
| Tom Manning | PK | 2009 |
| Kevin Martell | C | 1975 |
| Vincent Martino | DT | 1967 |
| Steve Marzur | E | 1953 |
| Nick Mazzie | K | 2024 |
| Cliff McDonald | T | 1968 |
| Brian McNally | DE | 2010, 2011 |
| Tad McNeely | OL | 2016 |
| John Merrill | OG | 1975, 1976 |
| Richard Mezquita | RB | 1960 |
| Don Miller | OT | 1971, 1972 |
| Phillip Montagano | E | 1956 |
| Gerry Morgan | OG | 1971, 1972 |
| Mike Moroney | TE | 1974, 1975 |
| Neil O'Connor | WR | 2017, 2018 |
| Peter O'Donnell | WR | 1981 |
| Bill O'Malley | DL | 1987 |
| Bob O'Neil | C | 1992 |
| Brian O'Neill | OL | 2012 |
| Matt O'Neill | C | 1992 |
| Seamus O'Neill | OL | 2012 |
| Duncan Ogg | C | 1962 |
| Curtis Olds | WR | 1986, 1987, 1988 |
| Jeff Pammer | FS | 2007 |
| Bill Pappas | QB | 1953, 1954 |
| Samuel Paul | QB | 1959 |
| John Perry | WR | 1991 |
| George Peterson | DE | 2004 |
| Tucker Peterson | OL | 2006 |
| William Phillips | RB | 1967 |
| Lee Pope | WR | 1977 |
| Chris Porter | OT | 1991 |
| Jordan Powell | TE | 2015 |
| Norman Powers | LB | 1970 |
| Charles Robichaud | C | 1955 |
| Dave Rozumek | LB | 1975 |
| Dylan Ruiz | DE | 2022, 2024 |
| Dwayne Sabb | LB | 1990, 1991 |
| Ricky Santos | QB | 2005, 2006, 2007 |
| Brain Saranovitz | OT | 1984, 1985 |
| Matt Schneible | OG | 1991 |
| Daniel Sereika | RB | 1962, 1963 |
| Mike Shaughnessy | RB | 1968 |
| Cam Shorey | DE | 2016 |
| Mike Shriner | RB | 1985 |
| Scott Sicko | TE | 2008, 2009 |
| Josiah Silver | DE | 2022, 2024 |
| Jared Smith | DT | 2012 |
| Wayne Smith | OT | 1976 |
| Hugo Souza | S | 2010 |
| Harold Spears | TE | 2014 |
| Barry Stiber | G | 1962 |
| Doug Stockbridge | DE | 1976 |
| Tim Teevens | DB | 1984 |
| Eric Thompson | DB | 1986 |
| Donald Trimble | T | 1958, 1959 |
| Bob Trouville | QB | 1956 |
| Will Tychsen | LB | 1989 |
| William Vasilios | DE | 1967 |
| Dino Basso | CB | 2010 |
| Grady Vigneau | OT | 1977 |
| Kurt Volherbst | DB | 1967, 1968 |
| Cal Wallingford | E | 1968 |
| Robert Weeks | T | 1962 |
| Mike White | OT | 1997 |
| Jonathan Williams | TE | 2004, 2005 |
| Dave Wissman | DB | 1984 |
| Al Witteman | DT | 1968 |
| Ted Wright | RB | 1955 |
| Neal Zonfrelli | LB | 1984, 1985 |